Introduction
Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes—presents a fascinating intellectual divergence, embodying a profound Dialectic concerning the supremacy of classical Antiquity vis-à-vis Contemporary Innovation. This spirited debate, which unfolded with fervour amid the salons and academies of 17th-century France, juxtaposed the reverence for the canonical Wisdom of Greco-Roman heritage against the burgeoning Self-assuredness of modern scholarship. The Anciens, staunch advocates for the enduring supremacy of classical paradigms, clashed with the Modernes, who championed the progressive virtues of contemporary Thought and Creativity. Through this contention, the Querelle underscored a vibrant disquisition on cultural and intellectual Values.
Language
The nominal "Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes," when parsed, reveals a multifaceted Structure rooted in the French lexicon. At its core, "querelle" is a feminine Noun, derived from the Latin "querela," meaning complaint or quarrel, encapsulating a concept of dispute or Argument. The Phrase "des Anciens et des Modernes" combines "anciens," from the Latin "antiquus," meaning ancient or former, with "modernes," from the Latin "modernus," implying something contemporary or Current. This Juxtaposition highlights a thematic Tension between Past and Present, Tradition and innovation. Etymologically, "ancien" traces back to the Proto-Indo-European root *ant-, referring to the fore or before, while "moderne" connects to the root *medyo-, signifying the middle or occurring just now. The combination of these terms into a nominal phrase reflects a historical debate over the Value of classical Learning versus contemporary thought, a concept deeply ingrained in cultural and Intellectual History. Though the phrase's Genealogy within literary and philosophical discourse is notable, its Etymology provides insight into the linguistic Evolution that frames such debates. "Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes" retains its French and Latin origins, serving as a linguistic marker of cultural Dialogue and intellectual contention through various periods. The nominal thus acts as a linguistic testament to the ongoing struggle between reverence for historical precedent and the pursuit of Modernity within the broader Context of human thought.
Genealogy
Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes, a term originating from late 17th-century France, embodies an intellectual debate that has evolved in meaning and significance across centuries, reflecting broader cultural and philosophical tensions. Initially emerging from literary and artistic circles in the Académie française, the querelle was a contest between those who revered the artistic and literary accomplishments of ancient civilizations—figures like Homer and Virgil—and proponents of modernity, such as Charles Perrault and Bernard de Fontenelle, who argued for the superiority of contemporary works. Key texts include Perrault’s "Parallèle des Anciens et des Modernes" and Fontenelle's "Digression sur les Anciens et les Modernes," which championed the Idea that modern achievements, informed by advancements in Science and Philosophy, surpassed those of antiquity. The discourse evolved from a literary debate to a broader cultural dialogue about Progress, , and innovation, intersecting with the rise of the Enlightenment and the valorization of Reason and empirical Knowledge. The querelle extended beyond France, influencing intellectual debates in England and other parts of Europe, as seen in the writings of William Temple and Jonathan Swift. Over Time, the term has been applied metaphorically to various dichotomies of tradition versus innovation in Art, science, and philosophy, thus Becoming a lens through which to examine cyclical tensions between reverence for historical achievements and the Impulse towards progression. The querelle’s transformation has underscored enduring questions about cultural authority, the Nature of progress, and the valuation of historical knowledge, making it a persistent symbol within intellectual history. Its genealogy reveals a layered discourse that reflects shifts in cultural attitudes and epistemological frameworks, illustrating how historical debates are continuously recontextualized to address contemporary anxieties and aspirations.
Explore Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes through classic texts, art, architecture, music, and performances from our archives.
Explore other influential icons and ideas connected to Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes to deepen your learning and inspire your next journey.
